PEI direct-play expertise · E² 100-hour evidence protocol · six value contracts
PUBLIC METHODOLOGY RECORD · NATIVE TECHNICAL REPORTS
EXPERT TECHNICAL EDITIONPalworld
PEI · E² · MPM · EMSQT · FULL FRAMEWORK DISCLOSURE
NATIVE ANALYTICAL RECORD · BASELINE 2026-06-21
Palworld: Native Decision Architecture
Five authoritative reports preserve the progression from observed experience to strategic direction. Each stage carries its own analytical question, evidence boundary, and decision right.
Rule-Only Constraint · one core anchor + five transitions · N#T# operator register
ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK ARCHITECTURE
PEI → E² → MPM → EMSQT
Expert interpretation establishes context; time-windowed evidence makes experience auditable; structured perception measurement separates value from variance; EMSQT converts the record into controlled decision stages.
Interpret play before formalizing evidence
Establishes the system context, player task logic, and expert reading required to distinguish designed friction from a decision-relevant failure.
Register experience across time
Structures direct observation into time-windowed evidence, tracking friction, passage quality, and changes in the governing value contract.
Measure perception without flattening variance
Separates modeled value, dispersion, and validation pressure. Every reading remains governed by evidence grade, variance, and its declared confirmation boundary.
Convert evidence into decision architecture
Progresses from evidence and evaluation through structure, diagnosis, and strategy while preserving the authority and boundary of every stage.
FULL METHODOLOGY DISCLOSURE
Native Framework Code Register
Every stage exposes the canonical analytical system used to produce its judgment. Framework names and report-level codes are public; internal file paths and production administration remain outside the analytical record.
E² PROTOCOL
6 VALUE CONTRACTS · 5 TIME WINDOWS
MDML 4.0 · MPM
54 ELEMENTS · 18 FIELDS · MVD-01–08
SFA · S1–S10
SYSTEM CAPSULES · DEPENDENCY · TRANSFER · LOOP
M-ABC · TVW
5 BOTTLENECK HUBS · DIAGNOSTIC LOCK
NTRIZ 40 · N#T#
RULE-ONLY CONSTRAINT · R0–R4 ROLLBACK
00 · AUTHORITATIVE REPORT ATLAS
Select the stage report required for the decision at hand.
E01
AVAILABLEE² EXPERIENCE EVIDENCE REPORT
PEI direct-play expertise · E² 100-hour evidence protocol · six value contracts
- VERDICT
- Palworld's exploration, capture, base operation and progression form a self-directed value loop. The primary evidence risk is not friction itself, but the point at which each value contract can no longer read, trust or choose a viable passage from friction to the next action.
- BASELINE
- 2026-06-21
M02
AVAILABLEMDML 4.0 PERCEPTION EVALUATION REPORT
MPM dual-perspective measurement · 18 fields / 54 elements · time, money and passion
- VERDICT
- Mechanism and long-horizon progression/ownership are the strongest perceived-value fields. Fairness, rule clarity and operational trust are the priority conditions governing additional investment.
- BASELINE
- 2026-06-21
S03
AVAILABLESFA STRUCTURAL LOCALIZATION REPORT
SFA S1–S10 system capsules · eight structural assets · loop and transfer architecture
- VERDICT
- Pal multifunctional assets and base automation convert world input into progression, validation and reactivation. Structural signals propagate across system boundaries rather than remaining inside individual features.
- BASELINE
- 2026-06-21
Q04
AVAILABLEM-ABC BOTTLENECK QUALIFICATION REPORT
One Diagnostic Lock · five secondary candidates · TVW damage and protected boundaries
- VERDICT
- The single confirmed core bottleneck is Growth Completion Route / Layer Attribution Visibility. Five secondary items remain T-design-track candidates, not confirmed secondary bottlenecks.
- BASELINE
- 2026-06-21
T05
AVAILABLENTRIZ 40 OPTIMIZATION DESIGN REPORT
Rule-Only Constraint · one core anchor + five transitions · N#T# operator register
- VERDICT
- Lock Growth Completion Route Lens as the immutable core anchor; attach five context-bounded transition lenses. The selected portfolio is four Conservative tiers and two Safe tiers, with every Aggressive tier held.
- BASELINE
- 2026-06-21
00 is a routing atlas, not a composite score. E, M, S, Q, and T are independent reports with separate analytical questions, evidence boundaries, and decision authority.
EE · EVIDENCE CAPTURE · AUTHORITATIVE NATIVE REPORT · 2026-06-21AVAILABLE
E² EXPERIENCE EVIDENCE REPORT
PEI direct-play expertise · E² 100-hour evidence protocol · six value contracts
Palworld's exploration, capture, base operation and progression form a self-directed value loop. The primary evidence risk is not friction itself, but the point at which each value contract can no longer read, trust or choose a viable passage from friction to the next action.
The E register converts PEI play expertise into the E² Protocol: five 0–100h observation windows, six non-averaged value contracts, hourly experience evidence and explicit confirmation coordinates for the downstream EMSQT chain.
DECISION-GRADE SIGNALS
Analytical coordinates for interpreting the stage verdict
0–100h
Five progression intervals
6
Independent player-value lenses
3 axes
Legibility · credibility · agency
8
Downstream behavior coordinates
PEI × E² PROTOCOL × EMSQT
Preserve designed friction; diagnose passage quality
PEI supplies expert direct-play judgment. E² structures that judgment as hourly quantitative, economic, offer and qualitative evidence across six player-value perspectives. E does not optimize; it establishes the experience facts that M, S, Q and T must inherit without inflation.
Expert play is the observation instrument
CANONICAL METHODSix high-skill value perspectives interrogate the same system through rule legitimacy, efficiency, completion, free-path continuity, convenience and upper-ladder proof.
Hourly evidence, not retrospective impression
EVIDENCE GROUNDThe first 100 hours are recorded as time, progression, economy, offer and fact-versus-perception evidence, retaining when and why a value transition occurs.
The passage, not friction, is the diagnostic object
PRESERVE / TESTCapture failure, base management, breeding delay and endgame rules can be designed friction. E asks whether the next viable action remains legible, credible and voluntarily selectable.
100-HOUR FRICTION REGISTRY
Value emphasis migrates across five E² time windows
Each interval pairs the dominant Palworld systems with its first decision cost and the passage expected to carry the player into the next interval.
- 0–1hRule acquisition and first value judgment
Player Level, Technology Points, Pal Sphere and Mission System establish the first rule, first capture attempt and no-additional-purchase progression path.
ENTRY VALUE- Primary task: rule legibility
- Observe first-failure explanation and retry option
- 1–6hAutonomous operation and first friction
Base Operation Hub, Agriculture, Factory Automation and Merchant introduce role allocation, production routing and price-purpose interpretation.
FIRST PRESSURE- Base-loop readability
- Merchant value boundary and upper route clarity
- 6–20hStorage, recovery and repeat routine
Global Palbox, Dimensional Pal Storage, Breeding and Item Retrieval shape the everyday rhythm of return and redeployment.
STRUCTURAL BRANCH- Delay and probability remain legitimate friction
- Storage and recovery must reconnect to a next objective
- 20–60hProgression payoff and economic choice
Pal Essence Condenser, Pal Surgery Table, Merchant, Token, Flea Market and Raid expose before-after value, completion cost and exchange interpretation.
VALUE BOUNDARY- Output visibility
- Credible convenience and completion delta after exchange
- 60–100hUpper validation and long-horizon contract
Raid, Arena, Dedicated Server and Shared Base validate progression output, fairness, common-asset trust and status value.
LONG-RUN VALIDATION- Server-rule and loss interpretation
- Permission, contribution and common-asset trust
PASSAGE QUALITY REGISTER
Three tests determine whether a recovery passage exists
A route is not viable merely because it is technically available. It must be legible, credible and actionable with resources the player can actually command.
Legibility · READ
After failure, delay or management load, can the player see the next action and the shortest valid route out of the blocked state?
Credibility · TRUST
Does the proposed route plausibly lead to progression, completion, recovery or a meaningful retry?
Agency · CHOOSE
Can the player choose among viable resources, time, exchange, storage or server options without coercive substitution?
CHURN × BUSINESS-MODEL REGISTER
Five offer-boundary functions separate value recovery from pressure
This is not a sales-quality score. It classifies what each commercial or currency touchpoint does to the player's recovery passage.
Free-path trust floor
Buy-to-play structure and the absence of a paid banner establish a protected floor for free continuation, price comprehension, collection and fairness.
Convenience and recovery
Surgery, Retrieval and Storage qualify as repair only when routine time or variance demonstrably falls after use.
Completion and proof
Breeding, Condenser and Surgery must convert duplication and correction cost into visible completion progress and upper challenge readiness.
External display value
External merchandise and IP touchpoints should read as preservation, display and identity rather than main-game power.
Unresolved value boundary
Merchant, Token and Flea Market remain ambiguous when free exchange, convenience and value proof cannot be distinguished at a glance.
PEI SIX VALUE CONTRACTS
One system is read through six independent contracts
The E² Protocol does not manufacture an average player. Each contract retains its own expected passage, first fracture and protected value.
Fair-comparison contract
Loss cause, server settings, win conditions and economic utility must separate strategic failure from rule failure.
- Passage: explainable rules
- Surfaces: Arena · Dedicated Server · Surgery · Flea Market
Time-to-output contract
Automation, storage and progression input must reduce management cost and expose a calculable route to the next objective.
- Passage: route and efficiency legibility
- Surfaces: Factory Automation · Palbox · Breeding
Collection-completion safety contract
Pal assets must move from acquisition to classification, correction, preservation and display; duplicates must return as completion progress.
- Passage: completion state and remaining distance
- Surfaces: Paldeck · Condenser · Global Palbox
Free-path survival contract
Capture, progression, storage and exchange must continue without additional purchase, while probability and reward rules preserve trust.
- Passage: free continuation
- Surfaces: Mission · Base · Token · No Paid Banner
Post-use convenience contract
Convenience value exists only when the player can read exactly which minutes and repeated actions disappeared after use.
- Passage: before-after delta
- Surfaces: Surgery · Storage · Merchant
Attainment-and-proof contract
Upper progression and status must remain public proof through Raid, Arena, server and common assets, not a direct paid bypass.
- Passage: upper-ladder proof
- Surfaces: Raid · Arena · Server · Shared Base
E² CONFIRMATION COORDINATES
Eight coordinates convert observed passage quality into testable behavior
These coordinates refine scale and timing; they do not replace the direct-play evidence or guarantee business impact.
Return and recovery
Test whether session spacing, storage/retrieval use and Shared Base participation lead to voluntary return.
Pre- and post-exchange behavior
Observe view, hold, use and revisit across Merchant, Token and Flea Market touchpoints.
Rule feedback after loss
Test whether rule view, retry and server selection close as a credible recovery route.
Continuation without additional purchase
Test whether free production, missions, exchange and cooperation sustain long-run progression without purchase pressure.
Input result and next objective
Observe whether delay, resource shortage and correction results clarify the next action.
Recovery of collection gaps
Test whether duplicates and correction results return to Paldeck completion, preservation and display.
Status outside the store
Test whether Raid, Arena, server and common-asset participation remain legible proof of upper value.
Interpretation boundary
Keep incomplete-source touchpoints in confirmation-pending status; do not impute or amplify unsupported values.
Do not remove friction; make the passage readable
Palworld's exploration, capture, base and progression depth are protected assets. Long-run trust depends on how the same friction resolves differently across six PEI value contracts and whether each contract retains a credible, selectable passage.
E supplies direct-play evidence and confirmation coordinates. Behavior scale and business impact remain unclaimed until the relevant validation evidence exists.
MM · PERCEPTION EVALUATE · AUTHORITATIVE NATIVE REPORT · 2026-06-21AVAILABLE
MDML 4.0 PERCEPTION EVALUATION REPORT
MPM dual-perspective measurement · 18 fields / 54 elements · time, money and passion
Mechanism and long-horizon progression/ownership are the strongest perceived-value fields. Fairness, rule clarity and operational trust are the priority conditions governing additional investment.
MDML 4.0 does not collapse perception into a satisfaction score. MPM cross-examines Provider structure and Customer value, then reads mean, rank, dispersion, evidence grade and persona divergence together.
DECISION-GRADE SIGNALS
Analytical coordinates for interpreting the stage verdict
2
Provider · Customer
18 Fields
6 Domains · 54 Elements
3
Time · money · passion
8 Cards
MVD-01–06 primary · MVD-07–08 supporting
MDML 4.0 × MPM × E²
Cross-examine what was provided against what was perceived
MPM means MDML Perspective Measurement. It is a dual-perspective instrument, not a satisfaction leaderboard: 54 elements are interrogated through Provider and Customer views, grounded by E² to reduce recency and peak-end distortion.
What the game supplies
27 ElementsD1 Core, D2 System and D3 Operation cover character/graphics/mechanism, progression/economy/structure, and probability/shop/event architecture.
What the player receives
27 ElementsD4 Experience, D5 Needs and D6 Engagement cover enjoyment/satisfaction/benefit, ownership/competition/growth, and fairness/stability/consistency.
Correct perception with direct-play chronology
GROUNDED / QUALIFIEDThe 0–100h E² record constrains recent-impression bias; cards remain supporting or conflicting-evidence review rather than standalone causal proof.
MPM 18-FIELD PERCEPTION PANORAMA
Read mean, rank, dispersion and PEI persona delta together
The score is a baseline, not a KPI. Rank, standard deviation, range and high/low-response contracts preserve both strength and uncertainty.
Character
60.98Pal role identity and base assignment signal asset value, while emotional attachment is not yet a stable driver of additional passion.
- Rank 17/18 · SD 8.74 · Range 30.95
- High: H3 · Low: H2, F1, V1
- MVD-02
Graphics
67.20Visual identity and display value are assets; quality trust and motion perception diverge by contract.
- Rank 11/18 · SD 12.51 · Range 45.24
- High: H1 · Low: V1
- MVD-05
Game Mechanism
81.35Exploration, capture and real-time combat produce the strongest immediate operating value in the panorama.
- Rank 1/18 · SD 10.60 · Range 30.95
- High: H3, V1 · Low: F1, L1
- MVD-06
Progression Provision
72.49Layered progression and upper challenges create a strong horizon, conditional on route priority and output explanation.
- Rank 5/18 · SD 13.68 · Range 45.24
- High: V1 · Low: L1
- MVD-01
Economy Provision
68.52Production and exchange are comparatively stable; purpose and post-use delta remain the monetary trust gate.
- Rank 9/18 · SD 6.07 · Range 16.67
- High: F1 · Low: H1, H3, L1, V1
- MVD-03 · MVD-07
Structural Provision
69.84Base, automation and storage create long-run operating value, with routine fatigue and common-asset trust as conditions.
- Rank 8/18 · SD 14.33 · Range 45.24
- High: V1 · Low: H3
- MVD-02 · MVD-04 · MVD-08
Probability / Reward Operation
65.34No paid-banner exposure is a free-path trust asset; unclear probability/reward grammar can still defer investment.
- Rank 13/18 · SD 10.68 · Range 35.71
- High: H3 · Low: V1
- MVD-07
Shop / Exchange Operation
71.03Merchant and currency access is comparatively strong; price purpose and post-use change control trust conversion.
- Rank 7/18 · SD 11.20 · Range 40.48
- High: L1 · Low: V1
- MVD-03
Event Operation
64.42Major updates and external extensions create return reasons, but main-loop linkage and repeat-participation comprehension remain costly.
- Rank 14/18 · SD 10.84 · Range 40.48
- High: F1 · Low: V1
- MVD-05
Enjoyment
71.56Immediate exploration/capture value and achievement support time investment; routine burden may cap it.
- Rank 6/18 · SD 10.87 · Range 35.71
- High: L1 · Low: H3
- MVD-02 · MVD-06
Satisfaction
72.75Achievement and progression reward are strong; completion closure and next-stage guidance condition long-run investment.
- Rank 4/18 · SD 14.00 · Range 40.48
- High: V1 · Low: F1, L1
- MVD-01
Practical Benefit
63.89Social connection and economic progression carry partial value; emotional relief and practical benefit remain limited observations.
- Rank 16/18 · SD 11.72 · Range 30.95
- High: F1 · Low: H1, H3
- MVD-08
Ownership Value
75.93Collection, storage and external display create strong ownership motivation; safety nets and cost legitimacy govern conversion.
- Rank 3/18 · SD 9.29 · Range 30.95
- High: H3 · Low: F1, V1
- MVD-02 · MVD-03 · MVD-05 · MVD-06
Competitive Value
66.40Upper objectives and status are legible; fairness, server rules and loss interpretation govern passion investment.
- Rank 12/18 · SD 11.30 · Range 40.48
- High: V1 · Low: H3, F1
- MVD-04 · MVD-08
Progression Value
76.45Progression is a strong reason to remain, but stage hierarchy, attribution and completion visibility can defer conversion.
- Rank 2/18 · SD 9.81 · Range 30.95
- High: H2, V1 · Low: F1, L1
- MVD-01
Fairness
52.65Explainable competition, server and reward rules are the highest-priority confirmation field.
- Rank 18/18 · SD 5.77 · Range 26.19
- High: H1 · Low: V1
- MVD-04 · MVD-06 · MVD-07 · MVD-08
Stability
64.29Long-run direction and resilience are mid-range; predictability across server, storage and updates remains conditional.
- Rank 15/18 · SD 9.22 · Range 30.95
- High: F1 · Low: V1
- MVD-05
Consistency
67.33Main game, external products and UGC must resolve into one coherent operational promise to sustain passion.
- Rank 10/18 · SD 7.18 · Range 21.43
- High: L1 · Low: V1
- MVD-05
MVD-01–08 · VALUE-DIVERGENCE REGISTER
Protected value and investment boundary coexist at the same touchpoint
Six primary MVD cards and two supporting cards remain independent. None is promoted to a standalone causal verdict.
Progression, Refinement and Completion
Pal Surgery Table, Pal Essence Condenser, Raid Boss Ladder and Global Palbox create a strong horizon; route guidance, output visibility and closure govern time/money/passion conversion.
Base, Routine and Storage
Base Operation Hub, Factory Automation, Agriculture and Global Palbox create the living system; queue load, route switching and closure govern time/passion.
Economy, Offer and Exchange
Flea Market, Gold Coin, Dog Coin, Bounty Token and Medal Merchant form an internal value-recovery network; price purpose and post-use delta govern money/time.
Competition, Challenge and Status
Dedicated Server PvP, Pal Arena, Raid Boss Ladder, Arena Rank and Battle Ticket create upper proof; rule transparency and loss interpretation govern passion/time/money.
External, Live and UGC
Version 1.0 release, Steam Workshop, Official Card Game and external bundles create return reasons; weak main-loop linkage can defer passion.
Core Exploration and Capture
Open-world exploration and Pal Sphere capture carry immediate value; first-failure explanation and retry resources govern continued time/passion.
Free Path and Probability Boundary
No Paid Banner Gacha and the premium/main-game structure protect trust; unclear probability/reward grammar can defer money/passion.
Social and Cooperative Value
Shared Base, Guild Chest and Dedicated Server participation become return value only when permission, contribution and reward are legible.
INVESTMENT CAPITAL × TRUST GATE
Time, money and passion are already invested under different conditions
M classifies trust as reinforcement, hold or stop; it does not infer one investment capital from another.
Time investment · CONDITIONALLY REINFORCED
Reinforced by exploration, base operation, progression and Raid; conditioned by guidance, routine load, completion and server rules.
Money investment · POTENTIALLY HELD
Opened by buy-to-play and internal exchange; conditioned by price purpose, post-use delta, probability/reward and premium boundary.
Passion investment · CONDITIONALLY SUSTAINED
Sustained by collection, display, upper challenge and UGC; conditioned by fairness, resilience and main-loop coherence.
Reinforcement candidates
Immediate exploration/capture feedback, asset preservation and a long progression horizon support additional investment.
Hold candidates
Price purpose, post-use delta, progression guidance and contribution-reward linkage can defer commitment pending confirmation.
Stop candidates
Opaque probability/rules, fairness damage and weak operational resilience can interrupt further investment.
MPM CONFIRMATION COORDINATES
Refine the eight MVD cards with behavioral evidence
The coordinates confirm direction, scale and timing; they do not convert MPM scores into market KPIs.
Progression result and next objective
Test whether correction, completion and retry preserve time, money and passion by exposing the next progression target.
Routine closure and return
Test whether base, storage and recovery lead to the next session without escalating management fatigue.
Post-exchange delta
Test whether exchange produces legible progression, completion or convenience value.
Rule view and retry
Test whether competitive loss closes into explainable rules, status and a fair retry path.
Return to the main loop
Test whether updates, UGC and external IP return players to sustained main-game value.
Action after first failure
Test whether resource recovery and redeployment remain a credible voluntary choice.
Probability/reward trust
Test whether no-paid-banner trust is reinforced by consistent probability and reward explanation.
Contribution and return
Test whether common assets, contribution and reward generate cooperative sessions and voluntary return.
Read conversion conditions, not scores in isolation
Mean is the baseline. Dispersion, evidence grade and value-contract delta determine interpretation. Strengths remain protected; low scores are not promoted to standalone causes.
MPM scores are structured perception measures, not official market-performance facts or individual-level behavior facts. They must be read with dispersion, evidence grade and persona delta.
SS · STRUCTURE LOCALIZE · AUTHORITATIVE NATIVE REPORT · 2026-06-21AVAILABLE
SFA STRUCTURAL LOCALIZATION REPORT
SFA S1–S10 system capsules · eight structural assets · loop and transfer architecture
Pal multifunctional assets and base automation convert world input into progression, validation and reactivation. Structural signals propagate across system boundaries rather than remaining inside individual features.
SFA — Structural Foundations Analysis — localizes responsibility across ten systems, eight protected assets, one world-integrated core loop, six secondary loops, ten transfer paths and ten Q-stage defect candidates.
DECISION-GRADE SIGNALS
Analytical coordinates for interpreting the stage verdict
10
S1–S10 structural capsules
8
Protected operating value
6
Growth · competition · cooperation · economy · RNG · reactivation
10
Cross-system signal propagation
SFA S1–S10 · STRUCTURAL CAPSULES
Separate the structural responsibility of ten systems
Each SFA capsule records composition facts, protected structural value, management tension and the next-stage confirmation point; it is not a feature-quality score.
Common operating specification
Direct player control, multifunctional Pals, real-time combat and persistent bases define the shared specification for all downstream systems.
- Asset: multi-role Pal conversion
- Tension: role overlap and choice cost
Progression supply portfolio
Exploration, capture, dungeon, Raid, expedition and mission surfaces supply materials and validation contexts.
- Asset: broad growth portfolio
- Tension: progression hierarchy and return priority
Optional upper validation
Arena and Dedicated Server PvP provide optional validation outside the PvE core.
- Asset: opt-in upper proof
- Tension: rule-baseline variance by server
Lifestyle cooperation
Co-op, Dedicated Server, shared storage and Shared Base convert non-combat contribution into group-stay value.
- Asset: non-combat contribution
- Tension: permission, contribution and common-asset trust
World-integrated accumulation
Deployment, recovery, base conversion and redeployment accumulate inside one world rather than independent modes.
- Asset: world-integrated loop
- Tension: base throughput and accumulated rule layers
Layered progression engine
Player, Pal, equipment, technology, capture efficiency, breeding and base operation form a multi-layer engine.
- Asset: progression depth
- Tension: contribution legibility by layer
Production-led multi-economy
Production, industrial resources, Gold, Token, trade and server settings create multiple supply-and-consumption regimes.
- Asset: automated production economy
- Tension: currency and server-economy baselines
Gameplay RNG supply
Wild capture, breeding, incubation, drops and rare encounters sustain collection without paid attempt rights.
- Asset: low payment aversion
- Tension: late-game time fatigue
Dual shop architecture
External Revenue Frontline and internal Merchant/Token/Flea Market Utility Exchange retain separate roles.
- Asset: dual shop structure
- Tension: discovery cost across internal/external value paths
Low-fatigue reactivation
Major updates, free seasonal rewards and collaborations reactivate the first nine systems through low-frequency, high-peak cycles.
- Asset: return without daily-task pressure
- Tension: re-entry gap between peaks
SFA STRUCTURAL ASSET MAP
Protect eight operating assets before intervention
A tension can be an overextended strength. SFA locks the operating value first so the next stages do not mistake an asset for a bottleneck.
Pal Multifunctional Asset
Combat, labor, mobility, breeding, trade and storage value cohere in one differentiated long-horizon asset.
Base Automation Hub
Pal labor and facilities transform world recovery into progression and economic assets, governing total-loop throughput.
World-Integrated Loop
New islands, Raid, storage, trade and cooperation accumulate in the existing world and renew return reasons.
Optional Competition
Arena and server PvP absorb upper-player validation while preserving PvE identity.
Lifestyle Cooperation
Combat, production, storage and Raid-preparation contributions convert into group-stay value.
Gameplay RNG Supply
Capture, breeding, incubation and drops sustain collection without paid attempt rights.
Dual Shop Structure
External Revenue Frontline and internal Utility Exchange protect immersion and business contact simultaneously.
Low-Fatigue Reactivation
Major patches, free rewards and collaboration create large return peaks without daily-assignment pressure.
WORLD-INTEGRATED CORE LOOP
Capture, conversion, validation and reactivation close inside one world
The Pal portfolio and base throughput are both initial inputs and reinvestment targets, allowing the core loop to close on itself.
- 01World Input
Player, Pal and base initiate exploration, capture, combat and resource recovery.
→ - 02Progression Supply
Exploration, Raid, expedition and mission supply materials and new objectives.
→ - 03Base Conversion
Pal labor, production, storage, crafting and research convert recovered inputs into growth and economic assets.
→ - 04Progression Accumulation
Technology, Capture Power, Souls, Condenser, Breeding and Surgery increase asset value.
→ - 05Validation / Cooperation
Raid, Arena, server PvP, co-op and Shared Base test progression and operating capability.
→ - 06Value Conversion
Merchant, Token, Flea Market and external product layers convert assets and currency into distinct value forms.
→ - 07Reactivation / Return
Updates, free rewards and collaboration refresh objectives and return the player to World Input.
SFA SIX SECONDARY LOOPS
Six satellite circuits reinforce the core
Each circuit is read independently to determine whether its output returns as input and where the seam becomes structurally weak.
Layered Progression
SEAM DISTRUSTAcquire resources → invest across layers → expand combat/production/operation → generate the next growth target.
- Technology, Souls, Condenser, Breeding and Surgery create priority cost
Arena / Server / Raid Validation
BASELINE DISPERSIONCommit progression output to opt-in validation, then return it as roster and base-strengthening motive.
Co-op and Common Assets
WEAK INSTITUTIONALIZATIONReturn joint production, storage and Raid preparation as a reason to reconnect.
Automated Production Economy
BASELINE VARIANCEWorld supply → base amplification → progression/facility consumption → exchange/recovery → production resupply.
Capture / Breeding / Drop
LATE-GAME TIME FATIGUEAttempt resources → probabilistic acquisition → collection/growth input → duplicate reuse → retry.
Major-Update Return
INTER-PEAK GAPLarge peaks refresh progression, cooperation, economy and shop interest simultaneously.
SFA TRANSFER PATH MAP
Ten structural signals propagate into other systems
Transfer paths are not confirmed bottlenecks. They preserve where Q must test priority and causal upstream position.
Pal Role Legibility
Role overlap → progression choice cost → asset-evaluation ambiguity → Growth, Economy and Contents Structure.
Progression Hierarchy Visibility
Loop accumulation → weak priority → failed objective transition → Growth and Event Systems.
Competition Rule Baseline
Server variance → dispersed fairness trust → weaker competitive stay → Economy, Event and Cooperation.
Common-Asset Trust
Shared storage/server operation → trust cost → weaker group stay → Contents, Economy and Event.
Base-Hub Throughput
Base friction → production delay → reduced growth/economy throughput → Basic, Growth and Economy.
Progression-Layer Overlap
Layer overlap → unread attribution → routine fatigue/investment delay → Growth, Economy and RNG.
Server-Economy Variance
Setting/trade variance → compressed progression curve → dispersed competition/cooperation trust.
Late-Game RNG Time Fatigue
Long repetition → perceived time loss → progression abandonment/event non-response.
Dual-Shop Discovery Cost
Distributed currencies, merchants and external goods → value-route discovery cost → lower exchange/purchase activity.
Event-Peak Dependence
Peak dependence → weaker interim return → weaker progression and shop conversion.
SFA STRUCTURAL DEFECT CANDIDATES
Ten candidates transfer to Q without diagnostic promotion
Each candidate marks a seam capable of interrupting a loop. Candidate status is preserved until Q completes M-ABC qualification.
Pal multifunction-role legibility pressure · Q CANDIDATE
Role overlap may propagate into progression choice, economic use and base-assignment error.
Growth-content hierarchy visibility · Q CANDIDATE
Content volume may obscure priority loops and break midgame or return-objective transition.
Competition-rule baseline dispersion · Q CANDIDATE
Arena/server rule variance may weaken fairness and validation-to-growth return.
Cooperation institutionalization / common-asset trust · Q CANDIDATE
Weak permission and contribution proof may thin group stay and social-capital return.
Base throughput / logistics legibility · Q CANDIDATE
Construction, routing and storage friction may constrain total-loop throughput.
Progression-layer investment decision cost · Q CANDIDATE
Unread contribution may convert depth into routine fatigue and long-horizon decision cost.
Currency separation / server-economy baseline · Q CANDIDATE
Trade and settings may split the official progression curve from server-level perception.
Late-game gameplay-RNG fatigue · Q CANDIDATE
Long repetition may become time loss while collection trust appears intact.
Internal/external shop discovery cost · Q CANDIDATE
Unclear role separation may defer both exchange and purchase.
Major-peak-dependent reactivation · Q CANDIDATE
Inter-update gaps may weaken progression re-entry and commercial conversion together.
SFA STRUCTURAL CONFIRMATION
Thirteen coordinates test whether structural signals appear in behavior
The coordinates test existence and propagation, not improvement magnitude.
Pal Interpretation Cost
Sorting, search, replacement and recovered misassignment.
Content Priority
First-entry order by level band and return timing.
Arena / Server Rule Trust
Entry, continuation, report and exit by rule regime.
Participation and Contribution
Co-op/server return, shared storage and reward collection.
Hub Throughput
Production interruption, pathing failure, storage search and relocation.
Contribution Recognition
Use order and stop points across progression instruments.
Server Variance
Acquisition, trade and penalty differences by server.
Loss / Permission Trust
Shared-storage loss, restoration and permission error.
Late-Game Time Fatigue
Attempt count, non-acquisition duration and post-farm exit.
Currency / Shop Discovery
Balance, merchant visit and failed-exchange patterns.
First-Session Objective
Whether return choice reconnects to the core loop.
Inter-Peak Gap
Connection and re-entry during event-absent periods.
Event–Shop Separation
Healthy independent retention and exchange behavior after free rewards.
SFA transfers a structural map; Q owns diagnostic lock
Assets, tensions, transfer paths and candidates retain separate statuses. A strength is not renamed a bottleneck, and a structural candidate is not confirmed before M-ABC qualification.
S localizes structure and candidates. It does not confirm the core bottleneck, prescribe solutions or claim performance magnitude.
QQ · BOTTLENECK QUALIFY · AUTHORITATIVE NATIVE REPORT · 2026-06-21AVAILABLE
M-ABC BOTTLENECK QUALIFICATION REPORT
One Diagnostic Lock · five secondary candidates · TVW damage and protected boundaries
The single confirmed core bottleneck is Growth Completion Route / Layer Attribution Visibility. Five secondary items remain T-design-track candidates, not confirmed secondary bottlenecks.
M-ABC qualifies the upstream hub and propagation path, then tests damage to Trust, Volition and Value (TVW). Candidate, guardrail and protected-asset statuses remain strictly non-interchangeable.
DECISION-GRADE SIGNALS
Analytical coordinates for interpreting the stage verdict
1
Confirmed core bottleneck
5
Not confirmed bottlenecks
4
Non-counted decision boundaries
9
Never counted as bottlenecks
M-ABC DIAGNOSTIC LOCK
Growth Completion Route / Layer Attribution Visibility
The bottleneck is not a lack of progression features. It is the failure of accumulated progression and completion layers to resolve into one readable result and next-goal route.
Growth Completion Route / Layer Attribution Visibility
DIAGNOSTIC LOCKWhen Breeding, Pal Essence Condenser, Pal Surgery Table, Ability Glasses, Large Incubator, Raid Boss Ladder and Global Palbox accumulate, players cannot reliably interpret what improved and what should happen next.
- M-ABC propagation: Design → Behavior → Commerce
- TVW damage center: Value; partial damage to Volition and Trust
- Risk surface: progression quality · completion trust · retention · routine fatigue · revenue quality · LiveOps trust
- Priority intervention node: progression hierarchy and layer attribution
THEORY AUTHORITY · 2 LEADING + 2 SUPPORTING
Four theories ground the locked diagnosis
The final Native report uses two leading and two supporting authorities; it does not invent a larger public theory count.
Rules of Play
Weak rule clarity, outcome visibility and possibility-space legibility prevent repeated action from becoming meaningful progression.
Flow Theory
Clear goals and immediate feedback sustain healthy retry and session continuity.
Self-Determination Theory
When progression choice does not support competence and autonomy, investment can become labor or fatigue.
Virtual Economy and Progression Curves
Unread cost and attribution increase the decision cost of economic choice and long-horizon value.
M-ABC SECONDARY CANDIDATE PORTFOLIO
Five propagation tracks remain candidates, not secondary diagnoses
Each candidate is a route through which the core damage may amplify across M-ABC hubs. None is promoted to a second core bottleneck.
First-contact / capture-rule passage
T DESIGN CANDIDATEIf cause, resource state and retry choice remain unreadable after first failure, voluntary re-entry may weaken.
- Protect immediate exploration/capture value and agency
Merchant / token / exchange-value passage
T DESIGN CANDIDATEIf post-exchange change is unreadable, Trust and Value decision cost may increase.
- Protect non-coercive internal exchange
Free-path / probability-transparency trust
T DESIGN CANDIDATEIf no-paid-banner trust and probability/reward explanation diverge, money and passion may be held.
- Protect buy-to-play and free-path floor
Competition / server rule / status fairness
T DESIGN CANDIDATEIf loss, settings and rank/ticket flow do not close into rule view and retry, competitive trust may be damaged.
- Protect endgame validation and public status proof
Cooperation / common asset / contribution trust
T DESIGN CANDIDATEIf permission, common assets, contribution and reward do not connect, cooperation may become processing labor.
- Protect low-intensity cooperation and common-asset trust
M-ABC REVENUE-QUALITY GUARDRAILS
Four non-counted boundaries prevent commerce misdiagnosis
Guardrails do not increase the bottleneck count. They protect purchase interpretation, trust, the free path and evidence integrity.
Merchant / token / exchange boundary · VIA QC-02
Separate free exchange, convenience and value recovery; do not reinterpret the internal exchange network as purchase pressure.
No-paid-banner / probability boundary · VIA QC-03
Do not replace the free-path trust floor with paid banners, opaque scarcity or more probability consumption.
Cooperation / common-asset trust boundary · VIA QC-05
Keep contribution and common assets separate from purchase or competition pressure.
Naming / economy / status interpretation boundary · NON-COUNTED
Do not extrapolate incomplete-source touchpoints into quantified performance claims.
TVW PROTECTED-ASSET REGISTER
Nine operating values are explicitly outside the bottleneck count
If a T direction damages these assets, it fails even if it appears to remove the bottleneck.
Long-Horizon Progression and Completion
Do not replace growth, refinement, completion and upper challenge with shallow reward pursuit.
Early Exploration / Capture Engine
Do not turn first-rule and capture value into over-guidance or forced onboarding labor.
Pal Multifunctional Asset
Do not collapse combat, labor, mobility, breeding, trade and storage into one function.
Base-Operation Routine Value
Do not interpret base, automation and storage only as fatigue; preserve autonomy and closure.
Free Path / Non-Paid RNG Trust
Do not damage no-paid-banner and free-continuation trust through aggressive monetization.
Endgame Validation / Status
Do not convert fair Arena, Raid and Server proof into loss defense.
Common Asset / Cooperation Trust
Do not make non-combat contribution and shared assets a source of social fatigue.
External IP / UGC Return Asset
Do not overuse external contact as a substitute for main-loop return and long-term display value.
Six Value Contracts
Do not optimize for a fictional average player; preserve contract divergence.
T DESIGN START CONDITIONS
Define where design may begin without prescribing the solution
Each track fixes the improvement object, protected asset and recovery condition. Contradiction, NTRIZ operator and implementation belong to T.
Progression hierarchy and attribution · T START CONDITION
Expose next target, output delta, contribution and retry continuity while preserving depth and completion value.
Retry after first failure · T START CONDITION
Expose resource state and next action while preserving immediate capture value and agency.
Value recovery after exchange · T START CONDITION
Expose growth, completion or convenience delta while preserving non-coercive exchange.
Separate free path and probability grammar · T START CONDITION
Distinguish continue, hold and purchase states while preserving free-path trust.
From loss to retry and status proof · T START CONDITION
Close loss, server rule and status flow while protecting fairness.
From common asset to cooperative return · T START CONDITION
Connect permission, contribution, reward and return while protecting low-intensity cooperation.
M-ABC DO-NOT REGISTER
Six prohibited directions protect the diagnostic boundary
Easy prescriptions that hide the bottleneck or damage TVW are excluded before NTRIZ design begins.
No reward inflation, paid bypass or cosmetic UI cover
Do not translate route-legibility failure into pressure, rewards or performance promises.
No forced tutorial or early shop pressure
Do not replace voluntary retry with forced routing or reward distribution.
Do not replace the progression route with currency sales
Do not translate unclear progression into a price anchor or external-purchase pressure.
No paid banner, opaque scarcity or FOMO
Do not replace free-path trust with more probability consumption.
No paid power or hidden loss cause
Do not process competitive loss through purchase bypass or unclear server rules.
No cooperation chores or unmanaged permissions
Do not convert common-asset and contribution trust into processing labor or social pressure.
Open the decision path; do not inflate the reward
Q locks one core bottleneck and its protected boundaries. Five secondary tracks remain candidates, while contradiction and solution ownership stay with T.
The five secondary items are design-track candidates, not confirmed bottlenecks. Diagnostic Lock is not execution approval, and validation is not proof of effect.
TT · OPTIMIZATION DESIGN · AUTHORITATIVE NATIVE REPORT · 2026-06-21AVAILABLE
NTRIZ 40 OPTIMIZATION DESIGN REPORT
Rule-Only Constraint · one core anchor + five transitions · N#T# operator register
Lock Growth Completion Route Lens as the immutable core anchor; attach five context-bounded transition lenses. The selected portfolio is four Conservative tiers and two Safe tiers, with every Aggressive tier held.
T inherits the Q Diagnostic Lock without re-ranking it. It formulates six contradictions, selects NTRIZ 40 operators, names the design directions, registers validation and rollback, and preserves the Rule-Only Constraint.
DECISION-GRADE SIGNALS
Analytical coordinates for interpreting the stage verdict
1 + 5
Core anchor · five transitions
6 × 3
Safe · Conservative · Aggressive
4C + 2S
All Aggressive tiers held
R0–R4
Monitor through revalidation
EMSQT HANDOFF × NTRIZ 40
Own prescription without reopening diagnosis
T inherits the Q bottleneck, then owns contradiction, operator selection, solution naming and validation design. The pipeline is F → C → NTRIZ operator → design direction → confirmation coordinate.
Diagnostic Lock remains fixed
Growth Completion Route / Layer Attribution Visibility is inherited, not re-proven or re-ranked.
Rearrange rules before adding content
Do not change probability values, prices, reward quantities or competitive formulas; do not add a new progression axis.
Game-design adaptation of TRIZ 40
N# identifies the NOVASMC operator family; T# maps to the classical TRIZ principle number. Codes and operational names are displayed together.
Trust · Volition · Worth
A local convenience gain fails when it damages trust, voluntary motivation or the recoverable value of time, money and passion.
LADDER 01 · CORE ANCHOR
Growth Completion Route Lens
Reduce interpretation cost while preserving progression depth, completion pressure and upper proof.
Layered Growth Readability Overlay
Expose the existing route in L1 route / L2 reason / L3 expert depth without changing systems.
ALTERNATIVEGrowth Completion Route Lens
Unify next target, output visibility, contribution coefficient, retry readiness and Paldeck update under one state grammar while keeping namespaces distinct.
IMMUTABLE CORE- N3T7 · Hierarchical Capsule
- N3T32 · State–Rule Encoding
- N4T5 · Integrated Hub
Unified Growth Completion Control Plane
Centralize all progression surfaces into one high-control operating plane.
HELDLADDER 02 · CAPTURE
First-capture retry clarity
Convert first failure into a chosen next action, not a stop state or automatic compensation.
Safe Capture Overlay
Retain capture rules and expose only failure cause, resource state and retry readiness.
ALTERNATIVERetry-Ready Capture Clarity Lens
Connect failure state → resource precheck → retry, replenish or redeploy, while preserving player choice.
SELECTED- N1T2 · Friction Extraction
- N3T32 · State–Rule Encoding
- N2T10 · Preliminary Loading
Fast Retry Path Compression
Compress already-seen checks and travel after repeated failure.
HELDLADDER 03 · EXCHANGE
Exchange-value boundary clarity
Expose recoverable growth, completion or convenience value without turning exchange into purchase pressure.
Mediated Conversion Trust Lens
Keep the exchange path and clarify outcome recovery plus internal/external roles.
ALTERNATIVEExchange Value Boundary Clarity Lens
Connect exchange_view → value boundary → item_use_result → routine_delta → revisit, hold or rebuy inside exchange-only surfaces.
SELECTED- N4T22 · Loss Assetization
- N3T4 · Intentional Asymmetry
- N3T32 · State–Rule Encoding
Routed Exchange Boundary Hard-Lock
Merge distributed merchant, token and trade surfaces into one exchange hub and common ledger.
HELDLADDER 04 · FREE PATH
Deterministic probability grammar
Protect free-path trust and attention budget; standardize interpretation without changing probability values.
Deterministic Probability Grammar Lens
Standardize the exposure order as state → probability → reward → cap/floor; values remain unchanged.
SAFE LOCK- N1T8 · Loss Buffering
- N3T33 · Homogeneous-Consistency Engine
- N3T32 · State–Rule Encoding
Free-Path Trust Buffer Clarity Lens
Attach free-path floor and probability-consumption boundary to existing surfaces.
REQUIRES COHERENCE REVIEWProbability Trust-Core Hard-Lock
Isolate probability, result and rule in a dedicated trust zone.
HELDLADDER 05 · FAIRNESS
Fairness status proof route
Turn competitive loss from an endpoint into rule view, status change and voluntary retry.
Consistent Fairness Grammar Lens
Standardize rule label, server badge, status change and report-state exposure order.
ALTERNATIVEFairness Status Proof Route Lens
Connect arena/server_loss → rule_view → rank/ticket_flow → retry/return_72h → report/ban proof without changing competitive rules.
SELECTED- N3T4 · Intentional Asymmetry
- N3T33 · Homogeneous-Consistency Engine
- N2T13 · Inversion
Integrity-Sealed Fairness Route Lens
Isolate match result, ranking and rule version inside a high-trust proof zone.
HELDLADDER 06 · COOPERATION
Permission–state grammar for common assets
Prevent cooperation chores by aligning minimum permission, contribution, reward and return grammar before adding functions.
Permission-State Route Grammar Lens
Align shared_base_action → permission_state_label → guild_chest_use → contribution_reward_status → return_reason with minimal functional change.
SAFE LOCK- N4T5 · Integrated Hub
- N1T39 · Integrity Isolation
- N3T32 · State–Rule Encoding
Shared Contribution Route-Guard Lens
Bind Shared Base, storage and contribution reward into one return route with permission precheck and congestion guard.
REQUIRES COHERENCE REVIEWSelf-Service Ownership Governance Guard Lens
Expose self-service ownership allocation, governance and audit.
HELDNTRIZ SELECTED PORTFOLIO · 4C + 2S
One immutable core and five context-bounded transitions
Four Conservative and two Safe tiers are locked together. Changing any transition tier reopens full coherence review.
- CORE · CONSERVATIVEGrowth Completion Route Lens
Unify progression hierarchy and layer attribution.
IMMUTABLE→ - TRANSITION 01 · CONSERVATIVERetry-Ready Capture Clarity Lens
Connect first failure to preparation, choice and retry.
SELECTED→ - TRANSITION 02 · CONSERVATIVEExchange Value Boundary Clarity Lens
Expose recoverable value and internal/external role boundary.
SELECTED→ - TRANSITION 03 · SAFEDeterministic Probability Grammar Lens
Standardize probability/reward grammar while protecting the free path.
SAFE LOCK→ - TRANSITION 04 · CONSERVATIVEFairness Status Proof Route Lens
Connect loss to rule view, retry and status proof.
SELECTED→ - TRANSITION 05 · SAFEPermission-State Route Grammar Lens
Align common-asset permission, contribution and return states.
SAFE LOCK
NATIVE TO-BE SYSTEM NARRATIVE
Preserve depth while reducing interpretation cost
The design does not average the experience. It specifies how the rule layer changes by progression interval.
- 0–1hFailure becomes a readable retry
Cause, readiness, replenish, target change and retry remain available in the same context.
→ - 1–20hBase routine reads as a progression route
Automation, storage and recovery connect to preparation and a reason to return.
→ - 20–60hDuplication, correction and exchange become recoverable assets
Before-after delta and remaining completion distance clarify Condenser, Surgery and exchange value.
→ - 60–100hUpper validation becomes external proof of progression
Raid, Arena, Server and Shared Base prove rules, fairness and contribution in distinct namespaces.
→ - SYSTEMUnify the core; isolate transitions by context
Progression information resolves into one route, while capture, exchange, probability, competition and cooperation proof appears only where needed.
TVW × SIX PEI CONTRACTS
Lock recovery and non-destruction together
An intervention fails when convenience for one contract erodes Trust, Volition or Worth for another.
Rules remain provable
Progression, exchange, probability, fairness and common assets must remain explainable proof.
- Prohibit paid shortcuts, FOMO and hidden loss cause
Actions remain voluntary
Retry, exchange, storage and cooperation remain contextual choices rather than mandated routes.
- Prohibit forced tutorials and chore cooperation
Investment remains recoverable
Time, money and passion return as completion, output, routine delta, proof or contribution.
- Prohibit new progression axes and reward inflation
Fair-comparison guard
Loss must close into rule and retry proof; no paid power or hidden cause.
Efficiency guard
Do not create drawer proliferation, route congestion or extra review queues.
Completion guard
Do not obscure duplicate-input results or flatten completion motive.
Free-path guard
Do not add paid banners, FOMO or external purchase pressure.
Convenience guard
Do not obscure post-use change to manufacture repeat-purchase rationale.
Upper-proof guard
Do not replace progression, status or contribution proof with a paid bypass.
VALIDATION PLAN · NO GUARANTEE
Test direction, side effects and requalification conditions
Validation is not proof of effect. No design is eligible for implementation approval without an application baseline.
Growth Route Legibility · DIRECTION
Test whether next-target and output visibility improve without completion stops or misreads.
Completion Output Visibility · DIRECTION
Test whether Condenser, Surgery and Raid results support real completion decisions.
Contribution Attribution · DIRECTION
Test whether personal progression and cooperative contribution remain distinct.
Retry Readiness · DIRECTION + SIDE EFFECT
Test clarity while monitoring exploration dwell and agency.
Resource Precheck · SIDE EFFECT
Test whether preparation is not read as shop direction or forced routing.
Value Boundary · DIRECTION
Test internal/external and free/paid separation without route congestion.
Post-Use Delta · SIDE EFFECT
Test whether change reads as value recovery rather than purchase pressure.
Probability Grammar · SIDE EFFECT
Test consistency without FOMO or paid-banner interpretation.
Status Proof · DIRECTION
Test proof without implying a competitive-rule redesign or black box.
Permission-State Grammar · DIRECTION + SIDE EFFECT
Test clarity without weakening cooperative return or increasing chore signals.
Pal Asset Passport · HELD VALIDATION
Test whether integration avoids becoming a new system and operating burden.
Trust Proof Ledger · HELD VALIDATION
Test whether proof avoids surveillance, control or operating burden.
ROLLBACK REGISTER · R0–R4
Pre-register five levels of retreat
Core and transitions have different risk windows; response escalates from observation to diagnostic revalidation.
Monitor Only
Separate value-contract and side-effect signals before action.
OBSERVEConfig Revert
Revert label, card, route-guidance or information-depth settings.
REVERTPartial Rollback
Stop exposure for a specific surface, server, contract or context.
PARTIALFull Rollback
Stop the action card and restore the prior implementation state.
FULLRevalidation
Reopen coherence, diagnosis or structural localization itself.
REQUALIFYACTION CARD RELEASE PACK
Eight independently governable implementation units
Each card owns an application surface and rollback route. Zero priority is baseline observation; no card starts without an implementation baseline.
Growth Completion Route Lens
Apply route hierarchy plus output and attribution grammar to existing progression/completion surfaces.
- Surface: progression · completion · UX
- Rollback: R1 → R3/R4
Capture Retry Readiness
Apply cause, readiness, choice and retry to first-failure surfaces.
- Surface: capture · retry · UX
- Rollback: R1 → R3
Exchange Value Boundary
Apply internal/external role and post-use delta to exchange surfaces.
- Surface: economy · exchange
- Rollback: R1 → R3/R4
Free-Path Probability Grammar
Standardize probability, reward, cap and floor exposure order.
- Surface: free path · probability
- Rollback: R1 → R3
Fairness Proof Route
Connect Arena/server loss to rule view, retry and status proof.
- Surface: competition · server rules
- Rollback: R1 → R3/R4
Common-Asset Permission State
Apply permission, contribution, reward and return grammar to Shared Base/Guild Chest.
- Surface: cooperation · common asset
- Rollback: R1 → R3/R4
Pal Asset Passport Pilot
UPSIDE CANDIDATETest a long-run read model across existing storage, progression, proof and display assets.
- Rollback: R2 → R4
Trust Proof Ledger Pilot
UPSIDE CANDIDATEBind free-path, fairness and common-asset trust at principle level while keeping screens separate.
- Rollback: R2 → R4
DECISION MENU A–D
The core is fixed; only transition safety may vary
Changing any one transition tier triggers full coherence review. No menu changes probability, price, reward quantity or competitive formula.
Balanced Coherence Lock
DEFAULT RECOMMENDATIONCore C + Capture C + Exchange C + Free Path S + Fairness C + Common Asset S.
Trust-Heavy Variant
COHERENCE REVIEW REQUIREDMenu A with Free Path restored to Conservative.
Social-Recovery Variant
COHERENCE REVIEW REQUIREDMenu A with Common Asset restored to Conservative.
Maximum Safety
COHERENCE REVIEW REQUIREDLower Capture, Exchange and Fairness transitions to Safe; prioritize rollback ease over recovery amplitude.
SIGNATURE CLUSTERS · UPSIDE CANDIDATES
Two clusters recombine dormant assets without creating content
Both clusters are held candidates. They do not replace the default portfolio or implementation approval.
Pal Asset Passport Cluster
HELDBind Paldeck, Palbox, Storage, Condenser, Surgery, Raid and Workshop into a readable time/use/preservation/proof history.
- No new collection or reward track
- No rollout before design and validation
Trust Proof Ledger Cluster
HELDBind free-path, competitive-fairness and common-asset trust under one principle while retaining independent namespaces.
- Do not create a unified surveillance screen
- Partial rollback if operating burden increases
This is rule innovation, not content expansion
The Growth Completion Route Lens remains the immutable core; five transitions attach only in their necessary namespaces. Every direction remains a design lock until baseline evidence and implementation approval exist.
Diagnostic Lock is not execution approval. Validation is not proof of effect. No probability, price, reward-quantity or competitive-formula change is authorized by this Native design report.